Is Rubber 3D Printing Possible and Do We Have Alternatives?

Last modified: November 4, 2020
You are here:
Estimated reading time: 5 min

As designers continue to grapple with the possibility of 3D printing rubber, we tell you whether it is achievable or not and go into detail discussing alternative rubber-like 3D printing materials.

Is it possible to 3D print the rubber? No.

Why not?

Rubber is an organic material whose properties cannot be influenced by external factors. The fact that rubber undergoes vulcanization — to improve its elasticity and strength — implies that it can never again exist in a fluid state. Vulcanization makes rubber solid and ensures it holds its shape. Any process of reheating it will cause it to burn.

Therefore, the mere fact that rubber cannot become fluid is the reason why it is impossible to 3D print rubber.

In this article, we explore rubber-like 3D printing materials that are excellent alternatives for those who want to 3D print rubber. In particular, we discuss how to print them and list some common examples. Although we’ll primarily focus on flexible filaments, we’ll also take a quick look at flexible resins.

Two prints made in soft PLA. Source: MatterHackers

Rubber-Like 3D Printing Materials: Flexible Filaments

A wrench printed in TPU.

Thankfully, there are rubber-like 3D printing materials that will make you feel like you are about to 3D print rubber. The most common ones are filaments made of thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs). TPEs can be used for several applications, some of which include shoe soles, flip-flops, and industrial applications like sealing rings.

Initially, printing flexible filaments caused designers a lot of trouble. That’s because these filaments were too soft, and whenever they went through a 3D printer, they didn’t print as expected.

Most extruders had the “pushing string effect”: Whenever a filament with no rigidity was pushed towards the nozzle, the filament bent or twisted because it was too soft. Thanks to the introduction of direct drive extruders, it’s now possible to print flexible filaments.

It’s important to note that flexible filament is a general give to flexible, rubber-like filaments coming from many different manufacturers. The formulas for these filaments vary from one manufacturer to another.

Rubber-Like 3D Printing Materials: Flexible Resins

A flexible watchband.

Apart from flexible filaments, the flexible resin can also be used to produce rubber-like prints. Flexible resins are a perfect choice when you want to develop or prototype highly precise flexible parts like gaskets, custom grips, stamps, and wearables, or when you want to add ergonomic features to your assemblies.

When printed, flexible resin feels just like rubber and will usually compress, “bouncing back” to their original form. The main drawback is that resins are normally designed for specific printers.

Here are three examples of flexible resin:

  • Formlabs Flexible Resin: Formlabs’ flexible resin is made for the Form 2 and will perform well under stress and extensive testing. It has a Shore hardness of 80A. Use it to produce bendable and compressible parts with resolutions of 50 to 100 microns.
  • XYZPrinting Flexible Resin: This resin is exclusively designed for the Nobel 1.0A printer. It has been tested by professionals and is guaranteed to give you superior quality and resilience. Its flexibility makes the prints bendable when subjected to forces while solid structures printed using it are impact resistant.
  • Type D Pro Flex: This epoxy-based resin by DruckWege is very flexible. It has improved properties (bending resistance and impact strength) and should be used on 3D printers with DLP/UV light sources.

How to 3D Print Flexible Filament

Printing with NinjaFlex.

The Basics

Your success with flexible filaments is primarily dependent on the printer setup and how well you can calibrate your printer. You’ll need a direct drive extruder because flexible filaments tend to “escape”. Even with the smallest gap in the filament path, TPEs will push through and mess up your print.

Flexible filaments have many “demands”, but they continue to grow in popularity as designers continue to explore new techniques. Today’s filaments are used in the hobby arena to create things like grips, RC tires, robot parts, and an array of other things that require a rubber-like feel or function.

Tips & Tricks

While these filaments will bring you joy in your quest to 3D print rubber, using them can be a nightmare if you don’t follow the right procedures. With these filaments, the more elastic the material, the more difficult it is to use. To get around the difficulties posed by flexible filaments, keep the following in mind:

  • Print slowly. Flexible filaments don’t do well under high speeds and need to be printed slowly. They take much longer to print compared to traditional filaments. 20–40 mm/s is a good starting point for most flexible materials, unless you have a specialized extruder.
  • Find the right temperature. Start with the recommended temperature for your rubber-like filament and go up or down until you attain the desired print quality. When the environment is too hot or too cold, you’ll likely get poor results.
  • The print head should not go outside the model. Ensure the extruder is within the model walls and not traveling over open air. This ensures the oozing is within the model walls. Most slicers have a setting for this.
  • Check retraction. When using rubber-like filaments, the retraction will bend the filament and cause jams. You should reduce it or turn it off completely.

Hire a 3D Printing Service

Due to the nature of rubber-like filaments, it may sometimes be easier to use a 3D printing service like FacFox, make use of high-end printers operated by professionals.

For a high-quality result, you can end up saving both money and time. All you need to do is provide the model and any accompanying instructions.

Flexible Filament #1: NinjaTek

Squishing a SemiFlex print.

NinjaTek claims to be the world leader in flexible filament, and they certainly have many varieties to offer. As an example, their SemiFlex filament is a tough, semi-hard flexible filament, which combines print resolution, shock absorption, and strength. It has a 98A Shore hardness and comes in a wide range of colors.

Flexible Filament #2: MatterHackers Soft PLA

Soft PLA from MatterHackers is a highly flexible material that feels almost like rubber. It is a great choice if you want to print parts that need to be bent. Examples are tires, phone cases, springs, machine parts, and toys. Soft PLA is a biopolymer that is created with natural materials, and even though it does not have the same elongation as co-polymer flexible materials, it is better than the standard, brittle PLA. The shore hardness is 92A.

Flexible Filament #3: Taulman PCTPE

A band made from 3-mm PCTPE.

Taulman plasticized copolyamide TPE (PCTPE) has unique characteristics that enable any designer to print a highly flexible part. This filament allows those with FDM 3D printers to print pieces ranging from cell phone covers to prosthetics and cosplay wearables.

The uniqueness of PCTPE implies that any finished print will have the added durability and the smooth texture of nylon. This is because PCTPE is a mashup of TPE and a chemical co-polymer of highly flexible nylon.

PCTPE is perfect if you need a print to be similar to but more flexible than Nylon. It’ll also print easily and quickly because it’s a less elastic version of TPE.

Although not explicitly stated, the Shore hardness of Taulman PCTPE is estimated to be over 100A.

Flexible Filament #4: Polymaker PolyFlex

PolyFlex is a TPU filament with a shore hardness of 95A. It’s the perfect choice for those looking for durability and high flexibility as it is known to stretch more than three times its original length.

PolyFlex will work on most desktop 3D printers and has a track record for printing well. The only concern is that it’s only available in 750-gram spools and the color range is limited.

Flexible Filament #5: FormFutura FlexiFil TPC

Flexible and environmentally-friendly.

FlexiFil is a bio-based flexible thermoplastic co-polyester (TPC). It boasts high performance and comes with unique strength properties. Items printed with this filament have a “flexural memory”, allowing them to return to their original shape or position after being folded, bent, or dented.

FlexiFil is resistant to chemicals, UV light, and has high impact resistance. It produces strong and durable prints that will rarely deform or break when stressed through bending.

FlexiFil is similar to SemiFlex and PolyFlex, though it is partially (43%) made of bio-oils. That makes it an excellent choice for the DIYer who is environmentally cautious.

Tags:
Was this article helpful?
Dislike 0
Views: 699

Continue reading

Previous: Durometer Shore Hardness Scale
Next: Inconel 718: The Main Force in Metal 3D Printing
Shopping Basket